Republicans Will Have Tactical Edge in Senate Impeachment Trial

‘What Republicans want to do is broaden the story…’

Mitch McConnell: Civil War, Civil Rights, and Obama Presidency Paid for Slavery

Mitch McConnell/Photo by Gage Skidmore (CC)

(Liberty Headlines) It’s been easy for majority Democrats to keep Republicans from shifting the focus of the House impeachment hearings. Yet GOP leverage to do just that will grow should the battle reach the Republican-run Senate.

If the House votes to impeach President Donald Trump, which seems likely, the Senate would hold a trial on whether to oust him from office, probably early next year.

There, attorneys for Trump, along with Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., or any other senator can call their own witnesses. The big catch is they’d need enough votes from the 53 GOP senators to muster a majority and prevent Democrats from blocking them.

Assuming Republican senators stay united, which isn’t guaranteed, Trump’s defenders could try refocusing the inquiry by seeking testimony from people like Hunter Biden, son of 2020 Democratic presidential hopeful Joe Biden.


Trump and some Republicans have pushed a narrative suggesting potential improprieties by Hunter Biden when he worked for Burisma, a Ukrainian natural gas company, while his father was vice president.

Calling witnesses about that — and another theory about Ukrainian involvement in the 2016 presidential election — could make life difficult for Joe Biden just as his party’s presidential primary season is beginning.

It would also please the GOP’s core conservative voters, woo some independents and perhaps help any wavering Republican senators stand by Trump on climactic votes over whether to remove him from office.

“What Republicans want to do is broaden the story,” said David Hoppe, who was chief of staff to Senate Majority Leader Trent Lott, R-Miss., during the 1999 impeachment trial of President Bill Clinton.

But calling such witnesses could be viewed as a blatantly political move that overreaches, risking voter backlash in next November’s elections. That might be especially damaging for moderate Republicans facing tough reelections in swing states, where centrist voters could be pivotal.

Sen. Cramer Says Renewable Energy Destabilizes Electric Grid, Urgent Action Needed

Kevin Cramer/Photo by Gage Skidmore (CC)

Sen. Kevin Cramer, R-N.D., said Thursday that he’d like Senate testimony from the still anonymous “whistleblower,” which some media outlets have identified as CIA operative Eric Ciaramella, whose House appearance has been blocked by Democrats.

That person’s complaint about a July telephone call between Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy triggered the impeachment investigation.

Cramer said he might also like to hear from both Bidens and Rep. Adam Schiff, D-Calif., who’s heading the House Democrats’ impeachment inquiry.

Asked if Republicans might overplay their hands by calling such witnesses, Cramer said: “Sure, it’s possible. I would hope political strategists won’t allow that to necessarily happen.”

McConnell will likely call “real witnesses on both sides of the aisle,” said Scott Reed, senior political strategist for the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and a long-time force in GOP politics. He said McConnell won’t “make this an easy vote for anyone. He’s focused on maintaining the majority” Republicans have in the Senate.

Republicans say McConnell is far from deciding which witnesses would testify and is unlikely to do so until the House completes its hearings, draws up articles of impeachment and votes on them. That seems likely to take the rest of this year, at least.

A major wild card is likely to be Trump, who might push his attorneys to pursue testimony from the Bidens or others involved with Burisma or the 2016 election.

“When this goes over to the Senate, you know, the people that actually started this thing, they are going to be put on the stand,” Eric Trump, the president’s middle son, told reporters Thursday. He said that would include “heads of the Democratic Party.”

Such demands would be certain to be opposed by Senate Democrats and would risk causing divisions among Republicans in showdown votes over how the Senate trial will be run.

A White House spokesman did not respond to several messages seeking comment.

McConnell and Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., have said they seek a compromise on the Senate trial’s procedures. Such a deal could address witnesses, whether they would testify in public and how long the trial would last.

With today’s jagged partisan differences, it’s unclear that a bipartisan pact on a dominating, prickly issue like impeachment is attainable.

McConnell said recently that he’d not yet held talks with Schumer.

“It’s way too premature,” Schumer said Thursday when asked about witnesses.

While House Democrats have largely dictated that chamber’s impeachment rules, Senate ground rules would tilt more toward Republicans.

Senate impeachment procedures allow witnesses to be called by the president’s defense lawyers and by a team of House Democrats who will in effect be the prosecutors.

McConnell and any senator can also offer motions to call witnesses. A majority of senators could reject the requests.

In a past example of lawmakers’ sensitivity about witnesses, Lott said he and Democrats agreed during Clinton’s trial that they wouldn’t let Monica Lewinsky testify in the Senate chamber.

Lott said he was concerned that Lewinsky, the White House intern with whom Clinton had an affair, would be asked about her semen-stained blue dress.

“I was willing to blow the place up rather than do that,” Lott recently told The Associated Press.

Her testimony was videotaped privately, and senators viewed excerpts.

Adapted from reporting by Associated Press.